If you are facing multiple criminal charges after a single incident, you may assume that each conviction will lead to separate punishment. In some cases, however, those convictions overlap or cover the same conduct. In Massachusetts, a conviction may be thrown out if it is based on a charge that has already been resolved. A recent decision from the state’s highest court shows how appellate review can correct errors and reduce sentencing exposure.
In a case reviewed by the Supreme Judicial Court, the accused was initially convicted of seven separate charges, including mayhem, multiple counts of assault and battery by means of a dangerous weapon, assault with intent to maim, and misleading a police officer. The altercation occurred after the accused gave a woman a ride home. A violent confrontation followed, resulting in serious injuries to another man. The jury returned guilty verdicts on several counts, but the SJC found that some of the convictions covered the same conduct and could not stand.