Since September 18, 2024, a Massachusetts abuse prevention order can issue on proof of coercive control alone, even where no physical harm or threat is alleged. The Legislature added coercive control that year to the definition of abuse that supports these Massachusetts restraining orders. An Appeals Court decision issued October 22, 2026, Kehlani K. v. Tripp T., interpreted that definition for the first time. It upheld a one-year extension of an order built on monitoring and unwanted appearances.
Under G. L. c. 209A, § 1, coercive control in its pattern form is behavior intended to threaten, intimidate, harass, isolate, control, coerce or compel compliance of a family or household member. It must cause that person to reasonably fear physical harm or have a reduced sense of physical safety or autonomy. Monitoring a spouse’s movements met that test.
Monitoring and Unwanted Appearances During a Divorce
The couple had been married 17 years and were in the middle of a divorce. A Probate and Family Court judge had given the wife sole use of the marital home. The husband kept appearing in her driveway, sometimes blocking her car in. He entered the house while she was out, once through a window, and photographed a calendar showing where she would be.
Her doorbell camera recorded him circling the house. He also turned up at a soccer game, at a child’s school, outside a movie theater in New York, and at her vacation rental. She testified that she felt she was being tracked. A judge in the Dedham District Court extended the order for one year after a hearing at which both sides testified.
How the Appeals Court Read the Definition
The court gave “pattern” its plain meaning, a series of acts that are recognizably consistent. It did not decide whether a pattern needs a minimum number of acts, while noting that the harassment prevention statute requires three. Intent may be inferred from conduct. Here the judge could find the husband used what he learned by monitoring his wife to press her to drop the divorce.
The court defined autonomy as “an individual’s ability to make significant decisions unfettered by concerns that doing so will expose that person to abuse.” The word “reasonably” applies to both the fear of harm and the reduced sense of safety or autonomy. The reaction must therefore be reasonable as well as real. Proof that the husband ignored the probate court’s order on the home supported that finding, as did his contact with her after the ex parte order was served.
The analysis rested on conduct, not speech. The court left open how a case built only on words would come out. It also noted that the Supreme Judicial Court has asked for briefs in a pending case, No. SJC-13947, on whether the coercive control provision is unconstitutionally vague or overbroad.
The Hearing After Notice for the Person Named in the Order
An ex parte order enters without the other side present. Section 4 gives the person named in it a chance to answer the allegations within ten court business days. If that person does not appear, the temporary order continues without a new court order. The person who sought the order must prove abuse by a preponderance of the evidence.
Any order runs for a fixed period of up to one year and can be extended or made permanent. Under § 3, a quiet stretch while the order is in effect is not, by itself, a reason to refuse an extension. Where the person seeking a temporary order shows a substantial likelihood of immediate danger of abuse, § 3B requires the court to suspend any license to carry and order every firearm surrendered.
Conduct after the ex parte order counts against the person named in it, as Kehlani K. shows. A violation of the order is a separate crime under § 7. The court also noted that it could not find a specific objection in the record to the limits the judge placed on questioning, before rejecting that challenge on its merits. Patrick J. Murphy represents people at 209A hearings and defends restraining order violation charges in the Boston Municipal Court and nearby district courts.
Contact a Boston Lawyer Before a 209A Hearing
A coercive control order can rest on conduct that never involved a threat. The Law Office of Patrick J. Murphy represents people facing abuse prevention orders across Boston and Suffolk County. The consultation is free for the first 60 minutes. Call (617) 367-0450 or send a message through the contact page to set one up.
Boston Criminal Defense Lawyer Blog

